What this is

duckspeak.news reads mainstream news outlets in the UK, the US, France and Ireland, and picks apart how they tell the same stories: the framing, the euphemism, the claim repeated without saying where it came from. The question is not whether a story is true, but how it is told. Which word was chosen instead of another? Which claim did four outlets repeat without checking its source? Why is an agency that should already know the answer quoted as caught off guard?

Two lenses

Both come from dystopian fiction. George Orwell's 1984 gives Newspeak (vocabulary built to narrow what can be thought), doublethink, and euphemism that turns meaning upside down. Aldous Huxley's Brave New World gives distraction instead of suppression: framing that makes readers accept things passively, or feel an urgency someone manufactured, without anyone telling an outright lie. The glossary defines each mechanism the critiques name.

Duckspeak

In 1984, "duckspeak" is the Newspeak word for quacking like a duck: speech that comes out of the throat without passing through the brain. That is the duck in the logo. Applied to news, it is several outlets running the same claim in almost the same words, because they all relay one press release or wire story and none of them checks it.

The tagline

Reading mainstream media the way it reads you. Coverage is tuned to its readers: which words will slip past them, what will frighten them, which enemy they are ready to blame, how much urgency will stop them asking where a claim came from. This site turns that scrutiny back on the coverage, word by word.

How a critique gets made

Every critique starts from real, current news articles. A language model analyses them for these framing patterns and writes a draft. Each quote or claim carries a number in brackets, like [1], that points to the source list. The site builds that list from the original articles, not from the model, so every source is a real outlet and link you can check.

A person reads every draft before it goes up. They edit the text, approve the illustration and its caption, and drop the drafts whose case is too thin.

Reading the posters

Each critique has a black-and-white poster with one element in purple. The purple marks the part of the scene that does the work of the mechanism: the spotlight, the label, the mask. The word under the poster, from one to three words and often taken from the coverage itself, names the piece's main mechanism. See them all on the posters page.

What this isn't

Not a claim that any outlet is lying, and not a partisan project: outlets across the political spectrum, in four countries, get the same treatment. The outlets page lists every one the critiques quote, and the barometer shows how often each mechanism turns up in an automatic sample of the press. Where the evidence for a critique is thin, the piece says so rather than overstating it. The point is the mechanism, not the politics of any particular story.

Spotted an error in a critique? Write to hello at duckspeak dot news.

Follow

Follow new critiques and, every Monday, The Week in Frames, a short video of the week's posters, on Bluesky and on Mastodon at @duckspeak@piaille.fr. No account? Subscribe to the critiques by RSS, or to the glossary feed for new entries.

See the privacy policy for what the site collects, or rather doesn't.