A critic who sees the problem

The Guardian’s review of Stacey Dooley’s Down the K Hole is an opinion piece, and much of what it argues is the kind of criticism this site would make. It complains that Dooley’s method is “repackaging what she has just been told, or giving voice to the feelings – sadness, frustration, resignation – she can count on the audience sharing” [1]. It wishes she would “move us all on from our shared understandings” [1]. That is a fair Huxleyan charge: television that soothes viewers by confirming what they already feel, instead of telling them something new.

The review also flags weak sourcing in the film. The 20% rise in admissions is “what we are told” [1]. It notices that “It is not really made clear what ‘embedded’ means” [1]. Those are useful flags for any viewer.

The evidence for a critique here is therefore thin, and what follows is limited. The review largely keeps its own standard. In a few places, though, it carries the documentary’s slogans forward in its own voice, which is the habit it criticises.

The headline promotes a quip to a fact

The headline promises “the weird tale of how you can order ketamine quicker than pizzaHeadline asserts, body hedgesThe mother pattern behind scare quotes, modal deletion, and the commitment-free statement: a headline states a claim as settled fact while the article underneath it quietly hedges, denies, or contradicts it.” [1]. In the body, that claim belongs to one person: “‘You can order pizza and ket, and the ket’ll come first,’ says Acorn resident Jensen” [1]. Jensen has been using the drug “almost every day for eight years” [1]. His line is vivid testimony from one heavy user about his own supply. The headline turns it into a general statement about how fast anyone can get the drug.

The mother pattern behind scare quotes, modal deletion, and the commitment-free statement: a headline states a claim as settled fact while the article underneath it quietly hedges, denies, or contradicts it.

This is a mild case of headline asserts, body hedges. The body does not hedge so much as attribute, but the effect on the reader is similar: someone who sees only the headline takes away a national delivery-speed claim that nothing in the article measures. To spot this move, find where the headline’s most striking phrase reappears in the text, and check whose mouth it comes out of.

“Horse tranquilliser” leaves the quotation marks

The review first presents the documentary’s tag as a quotation: “‘From horse tranquilliser to festival favourite,’ ketamine is the current recreational drug of choice among under-24s” [1]. A few lines later the phrase is the reviewer’s own premise, in an imagined warning from older people: “The clue is in the horse tranquiliser origin storyLoaded-vocabulary adoptionLoaded-vocabulary adoption is when a charged word coined by one side of a dispute ('raid', 'radical', 'ballooning') moves out of its quotation marks and into the outlet's own narration, so the argument is made before the evidence.” [1].

Loaded-vocabulary adoption is when a charged word coined by one side of a dispute ('raid', 'radical', 'ballooning') moves out of its quotation marks and into the outlet's own narration, so the argument is made before the evidence.

That is loaded-vocabulary-adoption. A film’s attention-grabbing tag becomes the reviewer’s own account of where the drug comes from. The reader is led to file ketamine as an animal sedative that young people have strangely chosen to take. The review never says whether the drug has any use in human medicine. A reader cannot tell from this text whether the “origin story” is the whole story or just the scariest part of it.

The passage is satire, voiced as older people “screaming” at the young [1]. Even so, the reviewer then endorses its substance: “Because, of course, that’s what it does” [1]. The tag has moved from the documentary’s script into the critic’s voice.

Crisis language on a figure with no base

The standfirst calls ketamine use among the young “a public health crisis in motion” [1], and the closing paragraph calls it “a gathering storm” [1]. The only population-level number offered is the 20% rise in admissions, which the reviewer has already said is merely “what we are told” [1]. The review gives no starting figure, no source and no indication of whether “admissions” means rehab places or hospital beds. A 20% rise could describe a few dozen people or many thousands.

The review mocks Dooley for doing no more than “point at the sky and say: ‘Look at those clouds!’” [1]. Yet its own storm language rests on the same unexamined statistic. The bladder damage described by Acorn staff is concrete and serious. The scale of the problem is asserted rather than shown.

The same gap, one step removed

The review faults Dooley because she “never drills down into why some people use but most others don’t” [1]. It also observes that the film offers “no other answer than ketamine’s cheapness and accessibility” [1]. The review does not supply those answers either. That is fair enough for a television review. It does mean the reader leaves with the same two images the film offered: pizza delivery and a horse.

What a reader would need instead

4 checks to run on the next story like this one.

  1. The source and baseline of the 20% figure. Who counts these admissions, and what do they count? Is it treatment entries, hospital episodes or something else, and how many people does the rise represent?

    Gap in the coverage

  2. The drug’s actual status. A reader needs to know whether ketamine has medical uses in people and how it is classified in UK law, before accepting the “origin story” as the whole picture.

    Loaded-vocabulary adoption

  3. Who supplies the clinical picture. “Ket bladder” appears here only through rehab staff. Urology services that perform reconstruction surgery, like the operation Josh is waiting for, would be the obvious body to ask how often they see it.

    Gap in the coverage

  4. Context on why use starts. This is the review’s own unanswered question. Treatment providers and public health bodies that collect data on who enters treatment, and why, could begin to answer it.

    Gap in the coverage