Two former leaders, no scoreboard

Lord Cameron told Bloomberg that the UK’s economic problems have “nothing to do with Brexit” and come from “overspending, over-borrowing, over-taxing” [2]. Andy Burnham answered the next day: “I think he is wrong to say that the low growth that we’ve had over the last decade is, quote, ‘nothing to do with Brexit’” [5]. His evidence was this: “the evidence says otherwise, and indeed the Treasury analysis says otherwise”Proof by invocationProof by invocation cites a report, a study or unnamed experts as having shown something, without giving a single figure, name or finding from them, so the reader can only take the conclusion on trust. [5]. GB News printed the same line, “the evidence says otherwise, and indeed the Treasury analysis says otherwise” [6], and did not follow it up either. This is proof by invocation. Neither outlet says which evidence, gives a figure from the Treasury analysis or says when it was published. So the reader can only side with whichever former or current prime minister they already trust.

Proof by invocation cites a report, a study or unnamed experts as having shown something, without giving a single figure, name or finding from them, so the reader can only take the conclusion on trust.

Look at what Burnham said the Treasury analysis shows: “if we are able to come to a good working arrangement on emissions trading, on agri-food, on other things as well, that we can add growth” [5]. That is a forecast about a deal that hasn’t been signed yet. A forecast about a future deal is offered as proof about the past decade. A model of what closer alignment might add cannot show what leaving took away, and neither report points out that one claim has been swapped for another.

The Independent has done this before in its own voice. On 26 October it described its campaign as resting on “clear evidence” that Brexit “has damaged the economy” [9], and the article gave no figures.

What the figures can and cannot show

The coverage could have offered more than a clash of assertions. From 2019 to 2025, UK real GDP grew 5.4%, but only 1.0% per head, because population growth accounts for most of it [13]. Over the same period real GDP per head grew 3.2% in France, 4.9% in Spain, 5.0% in the Netherlands and 8.8% in Italy, and fell 0.7% in Germany [12]. On headline growth over the last year the UK sits between Germany and France [11]. Cameron’s point about borrowing also has some support in the data: UK debt rose 18 points to 102.6% of GDP by mid-2026, with a 5.3% deficit in 2025 [13]. But France, inside the EU, added 20.9 points of debt and ran a 5.1% deficit [12].

None of this proves “nothing to do with Brexit”. It doesn’t prove Rachel Reeves’s “poorer, weaker and less secure” [10] either. Comparing countries tells you where the UK stands. It doesn’t tell you what a UK that stayed in would have done, which only models can estimate, and the pandemic years are not fully comparable [11]. Both camps make claims that the data shown here cannot settle, and the coverage tests neither.

The 0.4% growth figure goes the same way. On 11 November The Independent described “agreements he claims could boost GDP by 0.4%” [2]. A day later the same reporter wrote of treaties and a youth scheme “which could boost GDP by 0.4%Certainty upgradeA certainty upgrade restates a source's claim in the outlet's own voice more firmly than the source made it: a hedge, a limit or a caveat in the original disappears in the retelling.” [5]: the “he claims” had disappeared, a certainty upgrade that turns a government number into background fact. The BBC kept its attribution (“the government claims”) on a separate £5.1bn figure [7]. Only GB News tells readers that the 0.4% estimate “has not been published and therefore has not been scrutinised” [4].

A certainty upgrade restates a source's claim in the outlet's own voice more firmly than the source made it: a hedge, a limit or a caveat in the original disappears in the retelling.

“Surrender” with a hedge underneath

That same GB News piece shows the opposite problem. The headline reads: “Andy Burnham’s £15billion Brexit ‘surrender deal’Scare quotesScare quotes are quotation marks placed around a word an outlet won't stand behind, so it can print the word anyway.” [4]. The quotation marks have no speaker in the headline. The word belongs to Lord Redwood, quoted much lower down, so the outlet prints the charge without making it its own. These are scare quotes. The same device appears in a section label, “BREXIT ‘BETRAYAL’” [4].

Scare quotes are quotation marks placed around a word an outlet won't stand behind, so it can print the word anyway.

The rest of the headline says the deal “will help just 2% of British businesses”Modal deletionModal deletion is dropping a hedge word like 'could' from a headline, turning a hypothesis the article's own body still calls conditional into a present-tense fact. [4]. The body is more cautious: the deal “could tie 98 per cent” of firms to EU rules, and the analysis “has also suggested the deal may not have the impact Mr Burnham is hoping for” [4]. That is modal deletion: the body’s “could” and “may” become “will” in the headline. The 2% counts firms that export goods to the EU, which is not the same as the firms a food or energy deal might affect. The £15bn is a modelled “net opportunity cost” spread “across a five-year period” [4], not a price tag. The department’s reply, that “more than 91,000 UK businesses exported goods to the EU” [4], comes last.

Modal deletion is dropping a hedge word like 'could' from a headline, turning a hypothesis the article's own body still calls conditional into a present-tense fact.

The Lords story repeats the pattern. The headline says Britain is “to ‘adopt EU law every 12 hours’” [8], while the body reports that a farming deal “could result in at least 780 pieces of in-scope EU law every year” [8]. The committee chair’s actual point concerns scrutiny: “effective parliamentary scrutiny is essential” [8]. In GB News’s version, Britain is “swamped” by a “surge” [8] of rules.

A mild exchange, made loud

The GB News headline puts “‘you’re WRONG’” [6] in quotation marks. What Burnham actually said, printed lower down, was “I think he is wrong to say…” [6]. The narration says he “furiouslyAdjective inflationAdjective inflation is a dramatic modifier ('fiery denial,' 'bombshell') bolted onto a flat, uncontested sentence to make it read as a conflict story. hit back” after “a shocking intervention” [6]. That is adjective inflation: nothing in the quoted lines (“I think”, “It feels like”) is furious. The same thing happens when Redwood “fumed” [4]. Another GB News piece calls the policy a “plot to rejoin EU” [1], though Cameron spoke of an “argument” [1], and says Burnham “admitted” [1] a wish he had stated openly in October, “In my lifetime I would like to see that happen” [9]. Burnham now says “no one’s talking about rejoin” [5]. The BBC writes that he has opened “the door to the argument about rejoining… and even the EU altogether” [3]. No outlet sets these statements side by side and asks which one holds.

Adjective inflation is a dramatic modifier ('fiery denial,' 'bombshell') bolted onto a flat, uncontested sentence to make it read as a conflict story.

Who voted for what

The outlets disagree on what the 2016 vote means. GB News treats it as a closed decision: “More than 17.4 million Britons backed severing ties” [1]. The BBC [7] and The Independent [5] build their headlines around Burnham’s line, “more like the Brexit that people thought they were voting for” [5], which treats the vote as something politicians delivered badly and must now fix. No outlet asks how anyone knows what 2016 voters “thought”. A Scottish Labour MP quoted by the BBC raises the unasked question, “My view is you accept democracy” [3], and it goes no further.

What a reader would need instead

5 checks to run on the next story like this one.

  1. The Treasury analysis itself. Readers need the Treasury analysis Burnham cited: its title, its date and whether it looks back at the past decade or forward at a deal.

    Proof by invocation

  2. Like-for-like figures. They need GDP per head as well as headline growth, from the ONS for the UK and Eurostat for EU countries, together with debt and deficit on the same basis [13].

    Gap in the coverage

  3. The limits of comparison. They need it said plainly that comparing countries cannot show what the UK would have done if it had stayed in.

    Gap in the coverage

  4. The Lords report. Readers also need the Lords committee report itself.

    Gap in the coverage

  5. The modelling, hedges intact. They need the full modelling behind the £15bn and the 0.4%, with the hedges kept in the headline.

    Modal deletion